Skip to content
University of Exeter
EduExe

EduExe blog

Article5 min read

Demystifying Assessment and Feedback in the Law School: Scalable Approaches to Improving Student Confidence and Engagement

Law's 2025 NSS results showed that students on the Streatham campus were too often unsatisfied with the clarity of the marking criteria and the perceived fairness of the marking.

Law’s 2025 NSS results showed that students on the Streatham campus were too often unsatisfied with the clarity of the marking criteria and the perceived fairness of the marking. This correlated with feedback received through formal channels (such as student voice meetings, accelerate reports, academic appeals) and informal ones (such as office hours and meetings with student societies).

The NSS score for the usefulness of the feedback increased slightly in 2025, which suggested that, on balance, students appreciated their feedback but struggled to understand the parameters of their assessments, the marker’s expectations, and the link between the language of their feedback and the marking criteria.

This had wider implications. As well as the obvious links to NSS results and student experience, the reported lack of clarity indicated a gap in assessment literacy which may have affected some student outcomes and contributed to an awarding gap. Staff faced significant, almost unmanageable demand for office hour appointments and email traffic following assessment release points. The most common requests were for feedback clarification, despite feedback in the law school following HASS and sector norms on feedback and feedforward and being consistently praised by external examiners. Viewed in the context of the 2025 NSS scores, the root cause of these requests appeared likely to be one of assessment literacy and uncertainty in how to access appropriate support. There was confusion about what the marking criteria meant – what does the marker expect from a good ‘use of materials’? — and a lack of awareness of where, other than office hours, guidance could be found.

In short, we faced at least two challenges: to improve the clarity of the marking criteria and improve student understanding of who can help them with their study skills.

How we responded to these challenges

We first took stock of what support we currently offered students in relation to clarity of marking criteria, and how we can measure ‘fairness’. This stock-take identified many areas of good practice, such as the identification of feedback themes in academic tutor meetings, the inclusion of assessment criteria on assessment rubrics, Q&A on assessment in core modules, excellent study skills and referencing support from the library, and writing advice from Royal Literary Fund Fellows. This meant that, to an extent, a publicity exercise was needed to more effectively promote these resources to the student body at strategic times of year. That said, we also recognised that some areas of assessment support could have been improved. Demand on office hours needed to be reduced, and students needed further assistance with understanding the marking criteria.

Law marking criteria are complex. Students are assessed holistically across seven categories. These are presented to students in a table where relative strengths and weaknesses in each criterion are listed against indicative grade boundaries. Revisiting these criteria in their entirety would have been a significant task which could not be easily resolved in one summer. By contrast, more could be done to clarify each of these criteria.

The interventions discussed below were chosen because they were deliverable at scale, accessible, easy to understand, and built on existing support for assessment literacy. The response was not only resource-driven; we also worked hard to make space in timetabled teaching sessions to handle queries on assessment and feedback which may otherwise have been seen in office hours. We also made changes to the academic tutoring system so that students were encouraged to develop their reflection.

Student Support Infographics

Student support infographics were designed to direct students to existing and new sources of assessment support, as follows:

• Where do I go for support with assessments? – signposting where students can access support on assessment preparation, both in terms of general skills and substantive questions.

• Where do I go for support with a module? – guidance on how to access module-specific support

• Should I book an office hours appointment? – advice on when students should book an office hour and when other sources of support may be more appropriate.

• ELE gateway poster – featuring a QR code which took students directly to our ELE Gateway, which acts a central source for links to University-level student resources and law-specific guidance.

• Getting the most out of your feedback flowchart – designed to help students reflect on and understand their assessment feedback, complemented by worksheets which students could use to self-assess their feedback ahead of meetings with academic tutors.

These were shared with students in welcome and welcome back talks, in lectures, on screens in Amory, by links on assessment rubrics, by being printed and posted on office doors, and through student societies.

We saw a notable reduction in email queries and office hour demand, particularly during the global release date period, when almost 2,000 individual pieces of work were returned to students. This allowed us to concentrate our time on students who needed additional help. The 2026 NSS scores saw significant increases in most areas, notably on clarity of marking criteria and for the overall categories for ‘assessment and feedback’, ‘academic support’, ‘learning opportunities’ and ‘learning resources’.

Marking Criteria Videos and ‘Ask David’ live Assessment Q&A 

As mentioned, the law school’s marking criteria are complex. Student feedback had reported that the assessment categories themselves were hard to understand.

Law staff with education leadership roles were asked to film a 5-minute video explaining one of the categories and providing examples of what a good standard of work within it would do, aiming to demystify the formal assessment criteria. Presenters were asked to address the camera, be ‘chatty’, as if they had a student in their office who was asking them what their chosen category meant, and to refer to concrete examples. The idea was to capture the good advice given to students in office hours in a shareable and accessible way and debunk student myths such as the idea that a specific number of references were required to achieve a high mark. These were filmed on campus by the Student Experience Coordinator for Law (Laith Alobaidi) and uploaded to MS Clipchamp (formerly MS Stream), generating a link that was posted on the ELE Gateway.

Together, the videos covered all the marking criteria and an additional explanation of how they are inter-related:

  • How to demonstrate knowledge
  • How to demonstrate understanding
  • How to address the question
  • How to structure your essays
  • How to use materials in your assessments
  • How to reference accurately
  • How to conduct critical analysis
  • How to communicate effectively
  • Bringing it all together

As with the infographics, these videos were shared on the student ELE gateway and in other student-facing places. They were advertised in lectures, on assessment rubrics, in academic tutor meetings, and via email and student newsletters. QR codes were generated as part of a campaign to make the gateway as visible as possible.

These videos were complemented by an ‘Ask David’ Q&A session, held via Teams Town Hall, set up to coincide with the first tranche of summative assessments. This was hosted by the DESE, and was provided an opportunity for students to have their assessment questions answered and for myths to be corrected. Questions were submitted in advance and in the room; the recording was posted on the ELE Gateway, and a summary of answers was emailed to all students.

Impact and Reflection

Overall, these resources had a positive effect on student assessment literacy, office hour demand, and student satisfaction, as demonstrated by the improved NSS results and positive feedback from formal and informal sources. Although the ‘Ask David’ session was not as well-attended as predicted, the recording received over 180 views, meaning it played a valuable clarificatory role for students. In 25/26, these resources will continue to be advertised. We have built on them by developing a ‘getting started’ guide for law students, containing advice from students, staff and a leading law study skills text on topics including how to effectively prepare for classes and assessments.

Visit the EduExe toolkit to view the resources discussed in this article. You will also find adaptable templatised versions of the Student Support Infographics, Feedback Flowchart, and Post-Feedback Reflection Worksheet, and guidance on setting up an online Assessment Q&A.

Developing Assessment Literacy and Demystifying Assessment

The Hidden Curriculum – Student Support Infographics

Share

For more information

Written by Dr David Yuratich, Associate Professor and Director of Education and Student Experience, University of Exeter Law School